Amanda MaguireMore PostsWhich do you prefer?

Cookie dough or cooked cookies right out of the oven?

It’s a toughy, I know. But you have to choose….no riding the fence.

Comments 19 View Comments January 13, 2009

19 Comments

  1. Cookie dough all the way!

  2. no contest…definitely cookie dough!

  3. fresh hot cookies with ice cold milk!!

  4. Amanda (but not the official one)

    cookies right out of the oven with vanilla ice cream… to die for…

  5. I have been known to make the dough, and freeze some to bake later. Later never comes. Mmmm, cookie dough.

  6. Definitely fresh hot chocolate chip cookies!!! Especially accompanied with my hubby and a great movie (Breakfast at Tiffany’s) Ahhh… I can smell the aroma right now:)

  7. Chocolate Chip Cookies right out of the oven with a large glass of milk, TOTALLY!! (now you are making me hungry!!)

  8. Cookie dough!! Of course I am on a diet so both sound amazing right now!:)

  9. Fresh hot cookies – yummy!!

  10. Totally freshly baked cookies wins, handsdown, for me!! Of course, that’s not to say that I don’t eat many spoonfuls of dough while I”m making them too…

  11. Give me the dough.

  12. Well, being pregnant, I should choose the fresh, hot cookies! But, even I can’t keep from eating the dough while I make them. I do keep it at a minimum while pregnant though. So, I’ll vote for the baked ones since it’s better for the baby. Ask me again in five months and we’ll see if my answer has changed!:-)

    OH, by the way, thanks for making me crave chocolate chip cookies at 9:52 pm. It’s too late to make up a batch or I would!

  13. Seriously! Pray for my husband because I really am craving them now!

  14. Hot out of the oven. Jessica, I’m glad I’m not having cravings, I’m only 10 weeks prego, but chocolate has been one thing I really don’t want to eat anymore with this whole deal. I’d much rather go for fresh fruit. I don’t think I’ve had cravings, but lots of aversions.

  15. cookie dough hand’s down…the best? from papa murphy’s pizza in the little tub. delightful.

  16. fresh baked cookies for me!

  17. fresh baked right out of the oven…mmmmmm!

  18. For me its totally dough while the cookies are baking and then a couple of cookies warm but not so hot the chocolate chips burn your mouth (I’ve learned the hard way)

Leave a Comment

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>